-
derivative filename/jpeg
-
363-04964 to 363-04977.pdf
-
Digital Object Identifier
-
363-04964 to 363-04977
-
Title
-
Article about Dr. Thiện's remarks
-
Description
-
Original title: "thien", Keever's title: "Saigon Government Disagrees with U.S. Proposal for 'free delegations' Peace Talks, Throw(?) Legitimizing Viet Cong", Article draft about remarks made by Information Minister Dr. Thiện in response to U.S. Secretary of Defense Clark Clifford, for the Christian Science Monitor, page 1-13. Article starts with Keever's note to her editing for following article, page 1. The note is generally explaining the topic aqnd sources of the article.
-
AI Usage Disclosure
-
Draft transcripts were automatically generated via Google Document AI and are currently under review. Please report significant errors to Archives & Special Collections at archives@unl.edu.
-
Transcript
-
--------------------
- Page 1
--------------------
zczc sag
yy nnm
editorial note 1 (normass/deepe)
SAIGON, NOVEMBER 16--The following is excerpts and an abridgement of the official Vietnamese government's reaction to Clark Clifford's statement. This is based on a press conference with Ton That Thien, Minister of Information. There's no such thing as an official transcript of a Vietnamese press conference, so this must be considered an unofficial and rather rough (deleted) text. Also, some of the questions are summarized. We'll check over the week-end on political developments, but I don't think things are jelled well enough at this point to write about. Regards Bev.
==end reuter
--------------------
- Page 2
--------------------
zczc sag
yy nnm
thien 1 (normass/deepe)
SAIGON, NOVEMBER 16--Following is (deleted) unofficial (deleted) excerpts of the highlights of a press conference called by South Vietnamese Minister of Information, Dr. Ton That Thien, on Wednesday, November 13, to comment on the remarks of U. S. Secretary of Defense Clark Clifford.
I have convened this session because something has happened which is of very great importance. You have all seen the statement made by (deleted) Secretary of Defense Clark Clifford. He related what (deleted) President (deleted) Nguyen Van Thieu has said or has not repeat not said. And Secretary Clifford has said that President Thieu made a promise and then has gone back on his word.
==more reuter
--------------------
- Page 3
--------------------
zczc sag
yy nnm
thien 2 (normass/deepe)
Now I regret that a member of the Vietnamese government has to speak publicly on a matter like this. But, (deleted) we have no repeat no other alternative because a very high official of the American government has found it proper to make that kind of statement. I repeat again that at no repeat no stage, at no repeat not time with no repeat no one has President Thieu agreed to the "two sides-four delegations" formula.
Let me give (deleted) you the background of what happened. Normally a member of the government would not repeat not do this. But in this kind of situation we felt compelled to clarify matters.
On October 19, (deleted) (American) Ambassador (deleted) (Ellsworth) Bunker sent to President Thieu the draft of a joint communique on the bombing halt.
President Thieu declined to sign it. That was 15 days before the American election--because it was not repeat not clear what this "two-sides" meant and President Thieu wanted to find out what it meant.
==more reuter
--------------------
- Page 4
--------------------
zczc sag
yy nnm
thien 3 (normass/deepe)
Discussions went on about that until the 31st of October, when President Lyndon Johnson thought it necessary to ahead and announce the bombing halt unilaterally just before the election. But five days before--that is on the 25th (deleted) repeat 25th of October, President Thieu asked Ambassador Bunker why it was impossible for him (bunker) to modify his position on this four-delegation formula. And Mr. Bunker said that the American government had already made a commitment five months earlier, just around the time of the Honolulu Conference, so, that is the background of what happened.
I feel, I regret to have to say all this and I hope this is the first and the last time a member of the Vietnamese government has to disclose things which should not repeat not be disclosed at all.
==more reuter
--------------------
- Page 5
--------------------
zczc sag
yy nnm
thien 4 (normass/deepe)
But, I had no repeat no alternative after what Secretary Clifford said very jokingly--I say very jokingly--to the American press in Washington on such a serious matter.
Q. What happens if the U. S. government goes ahead with negotiations in Paris?
A. They have been doing that for several months now--but with things which do not repeat not concern us directly. No repeat no decision or formal agreement made without our participation (deleted) will be binding on us.
Q. Why do you think Secretary Clifford said this?
A. Well, I think, I don't know.
==more reuter
--------------------
- Page 6
--------------------
zczc sag
yy nnm
thien 5 (normass/deepe)
Q. Was the Bunker statement made on October (deleted) 25 the first your government (deleted) had ever heard about it (regarded the U. S. commitment to a four-(deleted) delegation conference in Paris, made at the time of the Honolulu Conference).
A. That was the first time President Thieu was told about it. He did not repeat not know anything about it at all before that time--four or five days before November 1. (The bombing halt was on November 1, Saigon time).
q. What was in the October 19th communique that Ambassador Bunker (deleted) presented to President Thieu?
A. There were two parts, one concerning the bombing halt and one concerning the peace talks. The bombing halt had very little to do with us...but other matters concerning the political future of Vietnam had to be discussed with us.
==more reuter
--------------------
- Page 7
--------------------
zczc sag
yy nnm
thien 6 (normass/deepe)
Q. Then was the communique not repeat not worked out with the Vietnamese?
A. That is correct. Well, you heard what Secretary Clifford said. Only the date was left out. President Thieu would never have (deleted) signed that. If he had, he would have been a puppet. He would have accepted to look in the eyes of the world as a puppet, and if he did that, it is no repeat no use for South Vietnam to fight on. Because we can never defeat Communism if we have a puppet.
Q. How did President Thieu take Secretary Clifford's statement?
A. I have not repeat not seen him today. But, he was in an unusual mood, if you like to call it that.
==more reuter
--------------------
- Page 8
--------------------
zczc sag
yy nnm
thien 7 (normass/deepe)
Q. What was the mood of the (deleted) government to Secretary Cliford's (deleted) statement?
A. It was one of shock--shock because the Americans are allies. A very high official in the American government made the statement--the third highest ranking executive in the American government, if I am right about the American constitution.
Q. How would you characterize his statement?
A. I can't not repeat not answer that because I do not repeat not think it is proper for high government officials to engage in this kind of thing. I hope it is the last time.
Q. Has anything near agreement yet been reached?
A. If you remember those three weeks before November 1, I insisted there was no repeat no agreement of any kind. To this day, there has been no repeat no agreement. If there (deleted) had been one, President Johnson would have been able to issue the joint communique in Washington and there would have been one in Saigon at the same time.
==more reuter
--------------------
- Page 9
--------------------
zczc sag
yy nnm
thien 8 (normass/deepe)
(deleted) Q. Is the South Vietnamese government in about the same position at the Paris conference as it was during the Geneva Conference of 1954?
A. that is a good refresher--when the French sat down and signed an agreement with the Viet Minh and we (South Vietnam) never recognized it and that's the root cause of the troubles all these years, because the war started again in five years. I don't know why people continue to assume that Vietnam would agree to things it has not repeat not participated in or signed.
Q. What is the reaction to Clifford's talking about two sides, not repeat not four parties in Paris.
A. Well, President Johnson's speech on November 1 mentions four-party talks in Paris. Or that's the (deleted) result, isn't it? We say that if you want to make that clear, you have to make it clear also that the National Liberation Front can not repeat not sit as a separate delegation. We said that 15 or 20 times. It's useless to go back to that. Also we can not accept to go to Paris without our separate South Vietnamese representation. We can have three-party talks, but never four-party talks.
==more reuter
--------------------
- Page 10
--------------------
zczc sag
yy nnm
Thien 9 (normass/deepe)
Q. What about Secretary Clifford's saying the only reason President Thieu refused to (deleted) agree was the South Vietnamese delegation was not repeat not ready to leave?
A. We never said that. That's Mr. Clifford's reason, not repeat not my government's reason. I assumed Mr. Clifford speaks for the American government.... (deleted
The only commitment we made in Honolulu was 'one man-one vote' principle. We said we would never accept the National Liberation Front. Sending the delegation to Paris is a very secondary matter. We are concerned with basic matters that have to be worked out first. But, if we have not repeat not raised the basic objection, we would have accepted almost anything that follows. Ambassador Bunker and President Thieu did not repeat not see each other for nearly sixteen days just because of one objection--there were many others....It's a waste of money and time to go to Paris and come home again."
==more reuter
--------------------
- Page 11
--------------------
zczc sag
yy nnm
thien 10 (normass/deepe)
Q. How do you explain these different interpretations (from what Clifford said)?
A. I hope it was a misunderstanding, but that is not repeat not the way it was put. I've been studying English for 30 years.
I think the misunderstanding is Ambassador Bunker put this paper before President Thieu, leaving a blank for the date, thinking President Thieu would sign it. And President Thieu can not (deleted) repeat not do it because he would appear in the eyes of the world and especially in the eyes of his own people as a puppet and he can not repeat not do that.
==more reuter
--------------------
- Page 12
--------------------
zczc sag
yy nnm
thien 11 (normass/deepe)
Q. Has anyone of Mr. Nixon's staff contacted high Vietnamese government officials?
A. I don't know. But I don't think Nixon would do that sort of thing behind President Johnson's back.
Q. What are the chances of going to Paris?
A. We're still waiting for either Washington or Hanoi to make new proposals and then President Thieu will study them and tell what he things about him.... To this date I haven't been told of any new proposals.
Q. What kind of guarantees is the South Vietnamese government seeking from Hanoi--a written statement?
A. It would have to be something for the whole world to know about. It is not repeat not good enough if an American representative meets a Hanoi representative in the kitchen and they talk and then they refuse to say aloud in the living room (what they agreed to). They should speak aloud in the drawing room so that everyone can hear what they have promised each other. So far, Hanoi has never done that they claim they have never done that.... We want things on the record. We want Hanoi to say publicly on what conditions it goes to the talks and whether it makes pledges, what kind of pledges it makes--on the record. It is not repeat good enough to be told it may agree to this or it may agree to that. That is not repeat not sufficient. It must be on the record. We have had (deleted) 25 years experience in the ways of Hanoi.
==more reuter
--------------------
- Page 13
--------------------
zczc sag
yy nnm
thien 12 (normass/deepe)
Q. Is that the only major issue?
A. It is not repeat not the only matter but it is one of the basic things.
Q. What about parallel negotiations--Saigon and Hanoi, the Americans and others?
A. We welcome to talk to Hanoi. Whatever else happens is not repeat our concern. If the American government wants to (deleted) talk to Hanoi also, they're free to.... We have never wanted to exclude the U. S. from anything.
Q. Secretary Clifford said there would have been considerable delay caused by President Thieu's objections?
A. President Thieu has said there are matters so vital, (deleted) rather than rushing into them, it is better to sit in Saigon than in Paris.
Q. Between what certain dates did Thieu make his conditions clear?
A. He has always made his views clear for over a year.
==more reuter
--------------------
- Page 14
--------------------
zczc sag
yy nnm
thien 13 (normass/deepe)
We have never been told anything about that commitment made five months earlier. Maybe someone has (deleted) forgotten to tell President Thieu about this....
Q. If the National Liberation Front sat at the other side of the table, but was not (deleted) repeat not (deleted) recognized by Saigon or the Americans--would that work?
A. That is not repeat not enough for us. The NLF can not go there as a separate delegation. The difference is that there will be three Vietnams, instead of two. This is not repeat not a matter of semantics. It is a matter of principle....
==end reuter
-
Date
-
1968, Nov. 16
-
Subject
-
Tôn, Thất Thiện (1924–2014); Clifford, Clark M., 1906-1998; United States--Relations--Vietnam (Republic); Vietnam War, 1961-1975--Peace; Press conferences
-
Location
-
Saigon, South Vietnam
-
Coordinates
-
10.8231; 106.6311
-
Size
-
20 x 26 cm
-
Format
-
dispatches
-
Collection Number
-
MS 363
-
Collection Title
-
Beverly Deepe Keever, Journalism Papers
-
Creator
-
Keever, Beverly Deepe
-
Copyright Information
-
These images are for educational use only. To inquire about usage or publication, please contact Archives & Special Collections.
-
Publisher
-
Archives & Special Collections, University of Nebraska-Lincoln Libraries
-
Language
-
English